1. What Investors Are Asking Right Now
Across the country, investors are deciding where to put their next dollar: single-family rentals or multifamily properties. Both can build lasting wealth, but each path requires a different mindset.
At Marketplace Homes, we work with investors who are just starting as well as those managing large portfolios. Some are building equity through single-family homes across multiple states. Others are moving into small apartment buildings to boost monthly cash flow. The most astute investors are discovering how both options can be combined to create a stable, diversified portfolio.
2. Understanding the Two Investment Types
Single Family Rentals (SFRs)
Single-family rentals are detached homes that are leased to a single household. They appeal to renters who want space, privacy, and stability. For investors, they’re simple to finance, easy to manage, and tend to attract long-term tenants.
Why investors choose them:
-
Lower purchase price and down payment
-
Simple financing through conventional lenders
-
Consistent tenant demand and longer lease terms
-
Easier resale options and potential for appreciation
Multifamily Properties
Multifamily properties comprise two or more units within a single structure, such as duplexes, triplexes, or small apartment buildings. They often require more upfront capital but deliver higher income potential.
Why investors choose them:
-
Multiple rental streams in a single property
-
Shared maintenance and operating costs
-
Scalable growth and improved cash flow
-
Lower impact from a single vacancy
3. What We See in the Marketplace
| Category | Single Family Rental | Multifamily Property |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | Lower entry point; accessible financing | Higher capital requirements; commercial lending is more common |
| Cash Flow | Steady income with fewer variables | Higher gross income potential per property |
| Vacancy Impact | One vacancy equals lost income | Occupied units offset turnover |
| Management Needs | Simple to self-manage or outsource | Requires professional systems and oversight |
| Scalability | Add homes one at a time | Acquire multiple units at once |
| Exit Options | Broader buyer pool and flexible sale | Stronger valuation per door, but smaller buyer pool |
Our property management data indicate that single-family rentals typically maintain a 97% occupancy rate across our national portfolio, while small multifamily buildings generate 20 to 30% higher monthly income per property. Both approaches can be strong performers depending on your goals and financing strategy.
4. How to Choose the Right Strategy for Your Stage
Every investor has a different goal. The right investment depends on your capital, time commitment, and long-term plan.
-
If you’re new to real estate investing: A single family rental provides an easier entry point.
-
If you’re ready to scale quickly: A small multifamily property increases cash flow and leverages economies of scale.
-
If you already own rentals: A mix of both can balance appreciation and consistent income.
Ask yourself:
-
How hands-on do I want to be?
-
Do I prefer flexibility or scalability?
-
What markets align with my long-term goals?
-
Is my priority income today or appreciation over time?
5. How Marketplace Homes Supports Both Investor Types
We specialize in helping investor-owners grow and manage rental portfolios across the country. Whether you own one home or fifty, our systems are designed to simplify every part of the process.
For Single Family Investors
-
Nationwide access to new construction and turnkey homes
-
Leasing, maintenance, and management are handled by experts
-
Detailed performance reporting through our investor portal
For Multifamily Owners
-
Full marketing, leasing, and management for 2 to 50+ unit buildings
-
In-house collections and eviction coordination through our legal partner Trowbridge
-
Rent optimization and portfolio performance analysis
Our Advantage
-
Licensed and active in 60+ markets
-
Experienced with both residential and multifamily assets
-
Builder and investor partnerships that unlock off-market opportunities
-
A single point of contact for acquisition, leasing, and management
6. Investor Scenarios We See Every Day
The Remote Portfolio Builder
A California investor partners with Marketplace Homes to acquire new single-family rentals in Huntsville, Columbus, and Tulsa. Our team oversees leasing, rent collection, and maintenance in each city while the investor tracks performance from one dashboard.
The Multifamily Expander
A Michigan investor transitions from five single-family homes to a 12-unit multifamily building. Marketplace Homes handles all marketing, leasing, and management. The investor sees improved cash flow, reduced maintenance costs per door, and steady growth month after month.
7. The Bottom Line
Single-family and multifamily investments both have strong potential. The difference lies in your capital, your goals, and your timeline. The most successful investors are no longer asking which is better but how to build both into their strategy.
When you work with Marketplace Homes, you gain a nationwide partner who helps you identify opportunities, manage assets, and scale confidently.
Discover how our all-in-one property management solution can help you unlock the full potential of your rental portfolio.
